Advertisement

Context:

1. Announcement on electoral reforms in the Budget speech.

2. While some considered it as a historic act of cleansing our polity, others saw it as a significant though inadequate step forward in the right direction.

The scheme of things:

1. First, he claimed to follow the Election Commission in proposing a ceiling of ₹2,000 on the amount of cash donation that a political party can receive from one person in a year.

2. Second, he announced that political parties would be “entitled to receive” donations by cheque or digital mode from their donors.

3. Third, he proposed a new scheme of Electoral Bonds.

4. Fourth, he said that every political party would have to file its Income Tax return within the prescribed time limit in order to enjoy exemption from payment of income tax.

5. He insisted that this scheme will bring about “greater transparency and accountability in political funding, while preventing future generation of black money”.

Analysis:

1. The second and the fourth components of this scheme are redundant, as these are no different from what the existing law provides for.

2. It does not require a new law to say that political parties are “entitled” to receive donations by cheque or digitally.

3. They were always entitled to this and were already doing so.

4. What the system needed, was a new law to mandate that the parties would be “required” to receive donations by cheque or digitally.

5. The existing law requires political parties to file their income tax returns to enjoy tax exemption.

6. The Finance Bill now proposes a new proviso in Section 13A clause (d) of the Income Tax Act 1961 that explicitly says that the return should be filed within the stipulated time limit.

7. So far, all major parties have routinely flouted this requirement and no one gets penalised for this non-compliance.

Limiting cash donations:

1. The proposal about limiting cash donations to ₹2,000 has been widely misunderstood and therefore welcomed as a first step in the right direction.

2. Everyone was foxed into believing that the limit for anonymous donations, contributions that are exempt from reporting, has been reduced from the existing ₹20,000 to ₹2,000.

3. This is what the Election Commission (EC) had asked for in its revised compendium of Proposed Electoral Reforms in December 2016.

Anonymous donations:

1. The existing limit of ₹20,000 on anonymous donation as per Section 23 of the Representation of the People Act (RPA) has been left untouched.

2. The Minister has merely proposed a new, additional, clause that limits cash donation from one source to ₹2,000 in one year.

3. Notice that there was and is no requirement to disclose a contribution by cheque or digital transfer up to ₹20,000.

4. There was and is no limit to how much a party can receive from anonymous donations.

5. More importantly, there was and is no limit to how much overall a party can receive in cash from all sources put together.

6. Following the Law Commission’s recommendations, the EC had proposed that no party should be allowed to receive more than ₹20 crore or 20% of its overall donations from anonymous sources. The Minister did not pay heed to this.

What difference will it make?

1. The proposal is unlikely to make any difference to the business as usual for political parties

2. The fact is that most political funds remain in the pockets of party leaders. A small amount enters the coffers of the party and becomes party funds

3. A tiny fraction of party funds is placed in the bank accounts of the party to meet some expenses that cannot remain invisible

4. Much of what political parties show as donations is black money generated by party leaders which is turned into white money by way of book entries as donations to the party

5. So far, the accountant who had to covert, say, ₹100 crore had to make sure than the entire amount was broken down into entries of ₹20,000 or below.

6. Now they will absorb the same amount by breaking it down into entries of ₹2,000 or below

7. All that the proposed law would ensure is more book entries and perhaps a higher fee for the accountant

Trouble with electoral bonds:

1. Anyone who wants to donate to a political party would be able to purchase bonds from authorised banks

2. This purchase will have to be in ‘white money’ against cheque and digital payments only

3. Once purchased, these bonds will be like bearer bonds and will not contain the name of the eventual beneficiary

4. These bonds shall be redeemable only in the designated account of a registered political party within a prescribed period

5. So, the donor’s bank would know about who bought how much of Electoral Bonds, but not the name of the party which received it

6. The party’s bank would know the amount deposited through Bonds, but not the identity of the donor

7. The Income Tax authorities and the EC would not know anything: reporting of donor, beneficiary, or even the amount of contribution has been exempted by amending the Income Tax Act Section 13A (b) and the RPA, Section 29C

8. The net effect, and indeed the purpose, of the Bonds will be that no one except the fund giver and the fund receiver would know about this exchange done in white money with full tax exemption

9. Once introduced, these bonds will mask whatever little transparency exists in the current system

10. Indeed, the black money in politics might go down, as the white money has been provided a perfect cover of secrecy

WHY IASTODAY IS BEST IN ONLINE COACHING?
FEATURESIASTODAY.inOTHERS
DAILY ANSWER REVIEWYES (in 60 minutes for core batch -before 10 PM for all lower courses)NO ( Not even weekly)
EXPERT SUPPORT24 hours x 7 days (In MASTER PLUS and above)NO/ During office hours only
GUARANTEE For Service & fee paid.Guaranteed till you clear (In LIFETIME membership)No guarantee at any cost.
Dedicated exclusive static testsYES(in MASTER PLUS and above)NO
TEST TYPEFull length similar to UPSC (In all dedicated courses)DEPENDS
FULL STATIC SYLLABUS COVERAGEYES (In all dedicated courses)DEPENDS
Full Day to Day current affairs coverageYES with review (All mains courses)NO
TEST REVIEW & MARKSYES throughout the course duration (In MASTER PLUS and above)YES during initial days.
NO after few tests
Effective cost for 30 MAINS static tests with reviewRs.10,000 (Master plus - Writing skill development 1 year)More than Rs.26,000
Flexible scheduleUnlimited. Reschedule based on demands.No flexibility.
Max delay in Mains Test review24 hours for core and In 4 working days for lower courses.Over 15 days
INDIVIDUAL MARKSYES (In all dedicated courses)NO
UPDATED NOTESYES(in all dedicated courses)NOT UPDATED

IASTODY DEDICATED COURSES IN A GLANCE

For 2023 & 24 Aspirants:
  1. Prelims TEST SERIES -PRO 2024- More than just a prelims test series for 2024 aspirants. 2024 PRELIMS in an integrated manner with mains and interview together with daily writing and review. {CLICK HERE for details}
  2. WRITING SKILL DEVELOPMENT(Daily review) (2 months- 6 months) Next is writing skill development- Available for 2 months and 6 months fixed. This can be used for 2024 or even 2025. Your answer will be reviewed as beginner in first day. Next day feedback will be based on first day performance and so on. You will develop a writing skill development better than aspirants outside IASTODAY by the end of this course- CLICK HERE TO KNOW MORE 
  3. DAILY REVIEW (Beginner) 2024 - Till mains 2024 We have Daily review (beginner) course available till Mains 2024. This course have 3 phases ie, Novice and then beginner phase till prelims examination and aggressive mode post prelims exam- You will write 1 answer a day as novice, then 2 till prelims and there after 4 daily.- CLICK HERE TO KNOW MORE
  4. ESSAY TEST SERIES 2023 & 24-Dedicated Essay test series for scoring high is now available for  2024. Real time exam environment, 24 hours accessibility and more @ a nominal fees-{CLICK HERE FOR DETAILS}
  5. Affordable Integrated Marathon (AIM 2024)-Dedicated All in one low cost series covering prelims test series, mains test series, daily answer review, interview, essay, optional and more in single version at lowest ever possible affordable version. Real time exam environment, 24 hours accessibility and more @ a nominal fees in comparison to features-{CLICK HERE FOR DETAILS}
  6. MASTER PLUS 2024-Dedicated mains 2024 @ Rs.50/day effective. Flagship MAINS 2024 program with all features including 29 mains tests, Daily answer review in 3-4 hours & value added notes and much more -{CLICK HERE FOR DETAILS}.
  7. PREMIUM 2024 - Full coverage @ Rs.55/day effective. Our Flagship prelims to interview with all premium features including daily answer review in 60 minutes, Prelims ,interview and much more -{CLICK HERE FOR DETAILS}.